more detail in contributions

This commit is contained in:
Emil Lerch 2026-09-05 11:32:16 -07:00
parent eae4299ad3
commit cee557d55a
Signed by: lobo
GPG key ID: A7B62D657EF764F8

View file

@ -1178,6 +1178,60 @@ fn collectUnmatchedLargeLots(
return out.toOwnedSlice(arena);
}
/// The kinds that carry real value but are deliberately left OUT of attribution -
/// and the only place that list lives.
///
/// Two consumers read it and they must never disagree: `compare`'s
/// "Uncounted in/out" headline and this report's own "Uncounted flows" total.
/// They would drift if each carried its own list, because these six kinds are
/// scattered across FOUR different print sections below (Cash deltas, Internal
/// purchases, Flagged for review, Lot edits) and nothing about the layout hints
/// that they belong to one bucket. That scattering is exactly why the headline
/// number was untraceable: every row was on screen and no total was.
///
/// `cash_delta` is the raw-balance-change bucket (an opted-in account's positive
/// delta is reclassified to `cash_contribution` at diff time and counted as a
/// contribution, so it cannot be double-counted here). The share-reduction kinds
/// are the other side of the same coin: `attributedValue()` pins them to 0 on the
/// grounds that they are a funding source rather than an outflow, which is right
/// for attribution and still worth SEEING.
///
/// Deliberately NOT here:
/// - `cd_matured` / `cd_removed_early` have their own section and always pair
/// with a cash increase in the same account, so counting both legs would
/// double-report one internal move.
/// - `transfer_in` / `transfer_out` / `unmatched_transfer` are DECLARED internal
/// moves (`transaction_log.srf`). The point of the total is UNdeclared
/// movement; a declared transfer is not a surprise.
/// - `price_only` carries no share change, so its value is zero anyway.
fn isUncountedKind(k: ChangeKind) bool {
return switch (k) {
.cash_delta, .drip_negative, .lot_removed, .position_closed, .lot_edited, .flagged => true,
else => false,
};
}
/// Gross in/out split of the uncounted flows, signed the way `compare` prints
/// them: `out` accumulates negatives, so `in + out` is the net and needs no
/// further sign juggling at either call site.
///
/// Uses `value()`, not `attributedValue()` - the whole point is the value that
/// attribution threw away. Note this is a DIFFERENT basis from the figure
/// `printCollapsedSales` shows for a sale, which uses `face_value` (what the
/// trade realized) and can legitimately differ from a current-price mark. That
/// is why only the Cash deltas section gets a per-section total below: there the
/// two bases coincide, so the section total and this one cannot disagree.
fn uncountedTotals(changes: []const Change) struct { in: f64, out: f64 } {
var in: f64 = 0;
var out: f64 = 0;
for (changes) |c| {
if (!isUncountedKind(c.kind)) continue;
const v = c.value();
if (v >= 0) in += v else out += v;
}
return .{ .in = in, .out = out };
}
fn summarizeAttribution(ctx: ReportContext) AttributionSummary {
// Aggregate. Classification logic matches the full-report sections:
@ -1198,37 +1252,15 @@ fn summarizeAttribution(ctx: ReportContext) AttributionSummary {
// `partial_transfer_in` -> residual only (attributedValue()).
var new_contributions: f64 = 0;
var drip: f64 = 0;
var uncounted_in: f64 = 0;
var uncounted_out: f64 = 0;
for (ctx.report.changes) |c| switch (c.kind) {
.new_stock, .new_cash, .new_cd, .new_option, .cash_contribution => new_contributions += c.attributedValue(),
.new_drip_lot, .drip_confirmed, .rollup_delta => drip += c.value(),
.partial_transfer_in => new_contributions += c.attributedValue(),
// Uncounted, and now reported rather than silently dropped. See
// `AttributionSummary.uncounted_in`.
//
// `cash_delta` is the raw-balance-change bucket (an opted-in account's
// positive delta is reclassified to `cash_contribution` at diff time and
// counted above, so it cannot be double-counted here). The share-reduction
// kinds are the other side of the same coin: `attributedValue()` pins them
// to 0 on the grounds that they are a funding source rather than an outflow,
// which is right for attribution and still worth SEEING.
.cash_delta, .drip_negative, .lot_removed, .position_closed, .lot_edited, .flagged => {
const v = c.value();
if (v >= 0) uncounted_in += v else uncounted_out += v;
},
// Deliberately NOT in the uncounted totals:
// - `cd_matured` / `cd_removed_early` have their own report section and
// always pair with a cash increase in the same account, so counting both
// legs would double-report one internal move.
// - `transfer_in` / `transfer_out` / `unmatched_transfer` are DECLARED
// internal moves (`transaction_log.srf`). The point of this line is
// UNdeclared movement; a declared transfer is not a surprise.
// - `price_only` carries no share change, so its value is zero anyway.
// The uncounted kinds fall through to `uncountedTotals` below, which owns
// that list. Everything else contributes nothing.
else => {},
};
const unc = uncountedTotals(ctx.report.changes);
// Cash-dest transfer attribution is already removed by `attributedValue()` on
// the per-Change side: `matchCashDestination` accumulates into
// `transfer_attributed`, so a fully-attributed cash Change contributes zero
@ -1237,8 +1269,8 @@ fn summarizeAttribution(ctx: ReportContext) AttributionSummary {
return .{
.new_contributions = new_contributions,
.drip = drip,
.uncounted_in = uncounted_in,
.uncounted_out = uncounted_out,
.uncounted_in = unc.in,
.uncounted_out = unc.out,
};
}
@ -3124,16 +3156,25 @@ fn printReport(out: *std.Io.Writer, report: *const Report, label: []const u8, co
try out.writeAll("\n");
// Section: Cash deltas
//
// Totalled, unlike the other uncounted sections, because this is the one
// that usually carries the bulk of `compare`'s "Uncounted in" and the one a
// reader ends up adding by hand. Safe to total here because these rows print
// `value()`, the same basis `uncountedTotals` uses - see the note there for
// why the sale sections are left alone.
try printSection(out, "Cash deltas (raw balance changes)", color, h_color);
any = false;
var cash_delta_total: f64 = 0;
for (report.changes) |c| switch (c.kind) {
.cash_delta => {
any = true;
cash_delta_total += c.value();
try printCashDeltaLine(out, c, report, color);
},
else => {},
};
if (!any) try printNone(out, color, mut_color);
if (any) try printTotalLine(out, "Total", cash_delta_total, color, h_color);
try out.writeAll("\n");
// Section: Internal purchases (internally funded - not counted)
@ -3236,7 +3277,7 @@ fn printReport(out: *std.Io.Writer, report: *const Report, label: []const u8, co
var buf: [256]u8 = undefined;
const msg = std.fmt.bufPrint(
&buf,
" {s: <12} {s: <24} (strict key broke, shares unchanged)\n",
" {s:<14}{s:<30} (strict key broke, shares unchanged)\n",
.{ c.symbol, c.account },
) catch " (lot edit)\n";
try cli.printFg(out, color, mut_color, "{s}", .{msg});
@ -3303,7 +3344,10 @@ fn printReport(out: *std.Io.Writer, report: *const Report, label: []const u8, co
total_cd_int += cd_int;
const acct_label = if (acct.len == 0) "(no account)" else acct;
try out.print(" {s:<28}", .{acct_label});
// 30 to match the per-change rows above. `Fidelity Emil 401(k) Roth BL`
// is 28 characters, so 28 left zero gutter and the next field butted
// straight up against the name.
try out.print(" {s:<30}", .{acct_label});
try printSummaryCell(out, " new", t.new_money, color);
try printSummaryCell(out, " drip", t.drip_confirmed, color);
try printSummaryCell(out, " rollup", t.rollup, color);
@ -3326,6 +3370,57 @@ fn printReport(out: *std.Io.Writer, report: *const Report, label: []const u8, co
// even though it originated inside the portfolio.
const grand = total_new + total_drip + total_rollup + total_cd_int;
try cli.printFg(out, color, h_color, " Grand total: {f}\n", .{Money.from(grand)});
// The figures `compare` prints as "Uncounted in/out", restated here because
// that line says "see `zfin contributions`" and until now nothing in this
// report added up to them. Same helper, so they are the same numbers by
// construction rather than by hope. Named sections so the rows behind each
// side can actually be found.
const unc = uncountedTotals(report.changes);
if (@abs(unc.in) >= 0.005 or @abs(unc.out) >= 0.005) {
try out.writeAll("\n");
try cli.printFg(out, color, h_color, "Uncounted flows (inside `Investment gains`, not attributed)\n", .{});
try out.print(" In: {f}\n", .{Money.from(unc.in).signed()});
try out.print(" Out: {f}\n", .{Money.from(unc.out).signed()});
try cli.printFg(out, color, h_color, " Net: {f}\n", .{Money.from(unc.in + unc.out).signed()});
// Name only the sections that actually contributed. Listing all four
// unconditionally would point at headings that were never printed
// (Flagged and Lot edits are both conditional), and it would put their
// titles on screen even when the sections are absent - which is not just
// untidy, it defeats any "this section did not appear" check.
var listed: usize = 0;
for ([_]struct { name: []const u8, hit: bool }{
.{ .name = "Cash deltas", .hit = anyUncountedIn(report.changes, .cash_delta_group) },
.{ .name = "Internal purchases", .hit = anyUncountedIn(report.changes, .sale_group) },
.{ .name = "Flagged for review", .hit = anyUncountedIn(report.changes, .flagged_group) },
}) |g| {
if (!g.hit) continue;
try cli.printFg(out, color, mut_color, "{s}{s}", .{ if (listed == 0) " from: " else ", ", g.name });
listed += 1;
}
if (listed > 0) try out.writeAll("\n");
}
}
/// Which print section a given uncounted change shows up under. Used only to
/// caption the total; `Lot edits` is deliberately absent because `lot_edited`
/// values to zero, so it can never move the figure it would be credited for.
const UncountedGroup = enum { cash_delta_group, sale_group, flagged_group };
fn anyUncountedIn(changes: []const Change, group: UncountedGroup) bool {
for (changes) |c| {
if (!isUncountedKind(c.kind)) continue;
if (@abs(c.value()) < 0.005) continue;
const g: UncountedGroup = switch (c.kind) {
.cash_delta => .cash_delta_group,
.position_closed, .lot_removed, .drip_negative => if (isSaleKind(c)) .sale_group else .flagged_group,
.flagged => .flagged_group,
else => continue,
};
if (g == group) return true;
}
return false;
}
fn printSection(out: *std.Io.Writer, title: []const u8, color: bool, hdr: [3]u8) !void {
@ -3350,7 +3445,7 @@ fn printChangeLine(out: *std.Io.Writer, c: Change, color: bool, pos: [3]u8) !voi
const val_str = std.fmt.bufPrint(&val_buf, "{f}", .{Money.from(c.value())}) catch "$?";
const acct = if (c.account.len == 0) "(no account)" else c.account;
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<24}", .{ c.symbol, acct });
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<30}", .{ c.symbol, acct });
if (c.security_type == .cash) {
try cli.printFg(out, color, pos, " {s}", .{val_str});
} else {
@ -3369,7 +3464,7 @@ fn printCdLine(out: *std.Io.Writer, c: Change, implied_interest: ?f64, color: bo
.cd_removed_early => "removed EARLY",
else => "removed",
};
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<24} {s:<16} face {f} maturity {s}\n", .{
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<30} {s:<16} face {f} maturity {s}\n", .{
c.symbol,
acct,
verb,
@ -3377,7 +3472,7 @@ fn printCdLine(out: *std.Io.Writer, c: Change, implied_interest: ?f64, color: bo
mat_str,
});
if (implied_interest) |i| {
try cli.printFg(out, color, cli.CLR_POSITIVE, " {s:<14}{s:<24} implied interest: {f}\n", .{ "", "", Money.from(i) });
try cli.printFg(out, color, cli.CLR_POSITIVE, " {s:<14}{s:<30} implied interest: {f}\n", .{ "", "", Money.from(i) });
}
}
@ -3385,7 +3480,7 @@ fn printCashDeltaLine(out: *std.Io.Writer, c: Change, report: *const Report, col
const v = c.value();
const acct = if (c.account.len == 0) "(no account)" else c.account;
const sign = if (v >= 0) "+" else "-";
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<24} cash ", .{ c.symbol, acct });
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<30} cash ", .{ c.symbol, acct });
try cli.printGainLoss(out, color, v, "{s}{f}", .{ sign, Money.from(@abs(v)) });
// Hint if a CD matured in the same account.
@ -3400,7 +3495,7 @@ fn printCashDeltaLine(out: *std.Io.Writer, c: Change, report: *const Report, col
fn printPriceOnlyLine(out: *std.Io.Writer, c: Change, color: bool, muted: [3]u8) !void {
const acct = if (c.account.len == 0) "(no account)" else c.account;
try cli.printFg(out, color, muted, " {s:<14}{s:<24} price {f} -> {f}\n", .{
try cli.printFg(out, color, muted, " {s:<14}{s:<30} price {f} -> {f}\n", .{
c.symbol,
acct,
Money.from(c.old_price),
@ -3413,15 +3508,15 @@ fn printFlaggedLine(out: *std.Io.Writer, c: Change, color: bool, warn: [3]u8) !v
try cli.setFg(out, color, warn);
switch (c.kind) {
.flagged => {
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<24} {s}", .{ c.symbol, acct, c.detail orelse "edited" });
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<30} {s}", .{ c.symbol, acct, c.detail orelse "edited" });
},
.lot_removed => {
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<24} {s} lot removed (face {f})", .{
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<30} {s} lot removed (face {f})", .{
c.symbol, acct, @tagName(c.security_type), Money.from(c.face_value),
});
},
.drip_negative => {
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<24} shares decreased on existing lot ({f})", .{
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<30} shares decreased on existing lot ({f})", .{
c.symbol, acct, Money.from(@abs(c.value())),
});
},
@ -3542,7 +3637,7 @@ fn printPartialTransferLine(out: *std.Io.Writer, c: Change, color: bool, pos: [3
const lot_value = c.value();
const sym = if (c.symbol.len > 0) c.symbol else "cash";
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<24}", .{ sym, acct });
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<30}", .{ sym, acct });
try cli.printFg(out, color, pos, " {f}", .{Money.from(residual)});
try cli.printFg(
out,
@ -3564,7 +3659,7 @@ fn printCashFundedResidualLine(out: *std.Io.Writer, c: Change, color: bool, pos:
const lot_value = c.value();
const sym = if (c.symbol.len > 0) c.symbol else "cash";
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<24}", .{ sym, acct });
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<30}", .{ sym, acct });
try cli.printFg(out, color, pos, " {f}", .{Money.from(residual)});
try cli.printFg(
out,
@ -3629,9 +3724,9 @@ fn printCollapsedSales(out: *std.Io.Writer, report: *const Report, color: bool,
// current-price proxy, so say which one the reader is looking at.
const basis: []const u8 = if (closed_in_place) "at close" else "at mark";
if (lots == 1) {
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<24} sold {s} ({f})", .{ c.symbol, acct, basis, Money.from(proceeds) });
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<30} sold {s} ({f})", .{ c.symbol, acct, basis, Money.from(proceeds) });
} else {
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<24} sold {d} lots {s} ({f})", .{ c.symbol, acct, lots, basis, Money.from(proceeds) });
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<30} sold {d} lots {s} ({f})", .{ c.symbol, acct, lots, basis, Money.from(proceeds) });
}
try cli.reset(out, color);
try out.writeAll("\n");
@ -3649,7 +3744,7 @@ fn printInternalPurchaseLine(out: *std.Io.Writer, c: Change, color: bool, muted:
const lot_value = c.value();
try cli.setFg(out, color, muted);
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<24} {f} from existing cash", .{ sym, acct, Money.from(c.internal_funded) });
try out.print(" {s:<14}{s:<30} {f} from existing cash", .{ sym, acct, Money.from(c.internal_funded) });
if (c.internal_funded + 0.005 < lot_value) {
try out.print(" (of {f} lot)", .{Money.from(lot_value)});
}